AWARD-WINNING PRESONAL INJURY LAWYERS Call Us Today (804) 358-1568

Emroch & Kilduff Logo
  • About Us
    • In the News
    • Attorney Referrals
    • About Us
    • Attorneys
    • Support Staff
  • Personal Injury
    • Virginia Car Accident
    • Virginia Truck Accident
    • Virginia Motorcycle Accident
    • Virginia Wrongful Death
    • Virginia Medical Malpractice
    • Virginia Slip & Fall Injury
    • Virginia Construction Accident
    • All Practice Areas
  • Locations
    • Richmond
      • Richmond Personal Injury
      • Richmond Car Accident
      • Richmond Truck Accident
      • Richmond Motorcycle Accident
      • Richmond Wrongful Death
      • Richmond Medical Malpractice
      • Richmond Slip & Fall Injury
      • Richmond Construction Accident
      • All Practice Areas
    • Tappahannock
      • Tappahannock Personal Injury
      • Tappahannock Car Accident
      • Tappahannock Truck Accident
      • Tappahannock Motorcycle Accident
      • Tappahannock Wrongful Death
      • Tappahannock Medical Malpractice
      • Tappahannock Slip & Fall Injury
      • All Practice Areas
  • Blog
  • Results
    • Testimonials
    • Our Results
  • Contact

Unguarded Drain Leads to Injury Recovery

Home >> Unguarded Drain Leads to Injury Recovery

Note: The recoveries in these cases are not necessarily indicative of recoveries in similar cases in the future, since each case must be decided on its own facts and circumstances. On January 20, 2007, the plaintiff injured his left knee when his foot shot out from under him and into an unguarded/uncovered drain hole. The injury occurred as he was wheeling a loaded handcart during an early morning delivery to the defendants’ restaurant. According to the plaintiff’s expert Charlie Crim, the uncovered drain and inadequate lighting to illuminate the drain were violations of the property maintenance code. The defendants actually admitted liability in response to requests for admission. Although an MRI of the plaintiff’s foot revealed a meniscus tear, this tear proved too small to repair, so a microfracture surgery was conducted to alleviate symptoms attributable to degenerative changes. The plaintiff had sustained a work injury to the same knee three months before the accident. That injury was also diagnosed as a meniscus tear. He had been released back to full duty prior to the drain hole accident. Although Dr. O’Brien, the defendant’s expert witness physician, stated that only the first three to six weeks of treatment were related to the accident, he conceded in his deposition that the surgery and up to 12 weeks of treatment were related and reasonable. Meanwhile, after first testifying in his de bene esse deposition that the accident was a precipitating factor for the future total knee replacement he had recommended, Dr. Beach, another expert of the defendant, admitted on cross-examination that the plaintiff would have eventually required the knee replacement anyway based on pre-existing changes. Dr. Beach then offered on re-direct that the accident was one of multiple causative factors. The physician was cross-examined with an early, contradictory draft of a report he wrote in the underlying workers’ compensation claim. The plaintiff’s wage loss claim was complicated by the fact that his employer subsequently fired him for alleged fraud related to his time clock usage. These allegations were rejected twice in the underlying workers’ compensation case, and a motion in limine to exclude this evidence was pending at the time of settlement. Although the results of a Functional Capacity Evaluation showed that he should be limited to medium demand work, the plaintiff already had the same restrictions for a prior shoulder injury. Dr. Sinsabaugh, the plaintiff’s expert witness, found a future loss of earning capacity lasting five years, while Gray Broughton, an expert for the defense, testified that similar paying jobs were available, even though the plaintiff applied for more than 180 jobs after being terminated. The plaintiff was simultaneously litigating both the workers’ compensation and personal injury claims. Despite having a subrogation lien, the compensation carrier aggressively defended the underlying claim. The personal injury case settled approximately two weeks after the original mediation, thanks to the efforts of mediator Mike Harman. Ultimately, the compensation carrier waived the subrogation lien of approximately $49,500.00, and the plaintiff was awarded $339,000.00. « Back to results page

Additional Personal Injury Settlements

Click on the links below to explore these cases and settlements in detail.
  • Brain Injury Victim Receives Largest known VA Award - $6.2 million
  • Injured Street Sweeper Settles for $650,000
  • Accident Victim Receives $1.5 Million
  • Disputed Brain Injury and Stress Disorder Victim Gets $600,000
  • Unguarded Drain Leads to Injury Recovery
  • Medical Malpractice case settles for $3 million
  • Automobile accident settles for $4.8 million
  • Truck Collision accident settles on second day of trial for $9 million
  • Natural Gas Explosion settles for $1.5 million
  • Truck Accident settles for $3.3 million
  • Bicycle Accident case settles for $1.3 million
  • Malpractice case settles for $900,000

Free Case Consultation

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Practice Areas

  • All Practice Areas
  • Medical Malpractice
  • Nursing Home Injury
  • Pedestrian Accident
  • Slip & Fall Injury
  • Wrongful Death
  • Wrongful Diagnosis
  • Construction Accident
  • Car / Auto Accident
  • Truck Accident
  • Bus Accident Injury
  • Bicycle Accident
  • Premises Liability Accident
  • Product Liability
  • Traumatic Brain Injury
  • Spinal Cord Injury
  • Aviation Litigation
  • Boat Accident Injury
  • Railroad Accident
  • Gun Accident
The service was nothing less than but professional top tier communication here I loved how I was treated here I would recommend them to anyone I know who’s looking for a lawyer cause my team was the best here from beginning to the end made me feel like family my opinion matter they had my back all the way and my best interest thank you guys so much.

Keenya M.

From beginning to end it was great knowledge of resources, teamwork and patience from E & K that built an indisputable case. Their knowledge and hard work while constantly preparing for trial lead to the insurance company realizing they had no recourse. Skilled negotiation lead to an acceptable settlement following my car accident with disputed liability. Highly recommended!

Randy. S

I am beyond grateful to Emroch and Kilduff for helping me with my accident injury case. William Kilduff and Anna Martin went above and beyond to get me the maximum amount for my case. They cared about me as a person, listened to my concerns, offered expert advice, and kept me updated throughout the process. I can’t say enough grate things about this law firm. If you want legal representation that’s going to put YOU first and go above and beyond for you, look no further than Emroch and Kilduff!

Christina S.

From my first appointment with this law firm I have been greeted friendly and professionally. My case was handled with my best interest to get compensation that was satisfactory to me in all areas involved for the service I trusted them with. I would definitely use them again if needed.

Deborah T.

Schedule A Free Case Evaluation

If you have been injured because of someone elses negligence, contact one of our experienced personal injury lawyers for a free consultation. For your convenience, Emroch & Kilduff has two office locations in Virginia: Richmond and Tappahannock.

Contact our offices today online or by calling (804) 358-1568 to schedule a free consultation, discuss the details of your injury, and determine the best path forward given your individual circumstances.

Free Case Consultation

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Emroch & Kilduff Logo

Richmond Personal Injury Lawyer

Richmond Office
7301 Forest Avenue, Suite 300
Richmond, VA 23226

Phone: (804) 358-1568 Map & Directions

Tappahannock Personal Injury Lawyers

Tappahannock Office
900 South Church Lane
Tappahannock, VA 22560

Phone: (804) 445-1507 Map & Directions

© Emroch & Kilduff 2025. All Rights Reserved.

  • Privacy Policy
  • Site Map

The personal injury attorneys of Emroch & Kilduff specialize in cases involving: medical malpractice, burn injuries, spinal cord injuries, paralysis, loss of limb, wrongful death, truck accidents, car accidents, motorcycle accidents, and defective products. The information provided in this website is offered for informational purposes only. It is not offered as and does not constitute legal advice. No attorney-client relationship will begin until after a contract has been agreed upon between Emroch & Kilduff, PLLC and the potential client.